I believe so. But I also think information can be dangerous.
Like... if you're about to jump over a hole, knowing how wide it is helps you a lot in judging how far you need to jump, right? But if you also knew that the hole was filled with snakes or something, you might decide to find another way around the hole, or that you don't really need to jump over it, eating up time you might have needed on the other side of that hole.
That's kind of an exaggeration, but it does show that information, while great, isn't king.
... Not every choice made will result in something overall good. Sometimes you can only aim for 'least worst' result. But from that kind of bad experience, you learn and you get better. You learn to handle poisonous snakes, and you learn to protect lives, and you learn what information may or may not be worth chasing. That's all still valuable information, though with a high cost.
I don't think it's an easy thing to know or tell. But... it depends on what you consider a 'mess up' probably. Holding yourself to unrealistic standards turns everything into a failure, so from the start you need to set a simple goal.
'Come back alive' or 'learn about this one thing' and the like. Set simple goals and keep in mind your limitations as a person. Thinking you'll come away from something you know is dangerous with everyone in perfect condition and all the info you needed, and every other thing perfect... that just hurts you more when even one thing goes wrong. And things can always go wrong.
What, like field trip stuff? We don't get out of here all that much, dude.
[He opens his mouth, to get more specific - pauses. Takes out a pad of sticky notes and scribbles on one one of them with a pen, then pushes it across the table. It reads: "just this one and one more," and he keeps his hand over it, to block the view of the cameras. When Mercury's seen it, he crumples it up and sticks it in his pocket.]
Just cause we been stuck here, though, don't mean there's not plenty to mess up right where we are.
A new location, people you've only recently come to know or remember, a set of abilities that are unreliable because of the source, your own memories largely missing...
All of those are negative factors against you. There's no way I'd expect someone to have a perfect go given those parameters. And I'd say it'd take plenty more before you could have any kind of actual success estimate be over... say 30 or 40 percent.
Which is why people have said every inch of information helps, because it lets us make better decisions. Prepares everyone for the next time and what to do to drive up those percentages even a little. To move those percentages up so we can have people come back in one piece.
... Running in blind's the equivalent of running in with a 5% chance that things will work out well for everyone.
Ah- to make it a little more complicated, sometimes charging is is exactly the right thing to do. The element of surprise and opportunity, right? It's just that there's a difference in charging in knowing what's on the other side of the door and having a rope around your waist to pull you back in if things go bad and not knowing and also not having any rope at all.
... Mistakes are one of the best ways to learn. They're just also one of the highest cost ways too.
Having a backup plan's always a good place to start.
As for the messing up... I'd say a better plan would be be accepting that mistakes happen. And they'll cost when they do. But pushing yourself to act perfectly is just as bad.
Re: Day 149, Morning
...yeah. I guess.
Re: Day 149, Morning
... Is there something about that you don't agree with?
Re: Day 149, Morning
We gotta know stuff.
Re: Day 149, Morning
Like... if you're about to jump over a hole, knowing how wide it is helps you a lot in judging how far you need to jump, right? But if you also knew that the hole was filled with snakes or something, you might decide to find another way around the hole, or that you don't really need to jump over it, eating up time you might have needed on the other side of that hole.
That's kind of an exaggeration, but it does show that information, while great, isn't king.
Re: Day 149, Morning
What if the snakes are poison and a bunch of people die and the info you get's probly not worth the trade.
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
What if, like - what if you mess it up every time?
Re: Day 149, Morning
'Come back alive' or 'learn about this one thing' and the like. Set simple goals and keep in mind your limitations as a person. Thinking you'll come away from something you know is dangerous with everyone in perfect condition and all the info you needed, and every other thing perfect... that just hurts you more when even one thing goes wrong. And things can always go wrong.
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
I just want to try and put things into perspective.
Re: Day 149, Morning
[He opens his mouth, to get more specific - pauses. Takes out a pad of sticky notes and scribbles on one one of them with a pen, then pushes it across the table. It reads: "just this one and one more," and he keeps his hand over it, to block the view of the cameras. When Mercury's seen it, he crumples it up and sticks it in his pocket.]
Just cause we been stuck here, though, don't mean there's not plenty to mess up right where we are.
Re: Day 149, Morning
A new location, people you've only recently come to know or remember, a set of abilities that are unreliable because of the source, your own memories largely missing...
All of those are negative factors against you. There's no way I'd expect someone to have a perfect go given those parameters. And I'd say it'd take plenty more before you could have any kind of actual success estimate be over... say 30 or 40 percent.
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
... Running in blind's the equivalent of running in with a 5% chance that things will work out well for everyone.
Re: Day 149, Morning
Yeah. Got it. Quit charging in.
Re: Day 149, Morning
... Mistakes are one of the best ways to learn. They're just also one of the highest cost ways too.
Re: Day 149, Morning
So, what, the takeaway's get a rope and mess up less?
Re: Day 149, Morning
As for the messing up... I'd say a better plan would be be accepting that mistakes happen. And they'll cost when they do. But pushing yourself to act perfectly is just as bad.
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
[Glances aside.]
...sorry.
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning
Re: Day 149, Morning